One of these arrows was built for the biggest big game animal in North America, the Alaska moose. The other was built for one of the smallest, the pronghorn. The difference between them is not what you think.
The internet says your pronghorn arrow should be flat, fast, and light, around 400 to 450 grains, and your moose arrow should be 550 to 600. I built both from scratch, weighed them, and ran them through a chronograph. Here’s what I found, and why I’ve stopped building arrows for the animal.
My Arrow Building Philosophy
I want my arrow to stay as flat as possible, and I want it to penetrate as much as possible. I don’t want it so light that I’m basically throwing a straw at an animal. But I don’t want it so heavy that I’ve got a huge arc in my arrow.
When I talk about penetration, here’s what I mean. If I hit a shoulder, I want that arrow to get through the shoulder. If I hit a rib, I want it to get through the rib into the vitals. If I miss bone, I want it to go all the way through so I have two holes. Two holes means more blood. The animal dies faster, and you have a bigger trail to track. Penetration, in my opinion, is super important.
The Build, Step by Step
The shaft: Day Six XR, 250 spine
I shoot a Day Six XR in a 250 spine. It’s a nice light shaft, super tough, and the straightness is really good. I pull an 80-pound bow, so I need a stiff spine. I don’t want the arrow bending too much coming out of the bow.
Cut it to length
I don’t want a lot of arrow sticking out past my bow, because more arrow means more material and more weight. I cut mine to 27¼ inches, which leaves about half an inch to three-quarters of an inch past the bow with the insert in. Cut it, square the end, and clean it off with a rag so your glue holds.
Insert: 75-grain half-out
I stayed with Day Six and put in a 75-grain half-out insert. Part of it goes inside the shaft and part of it wraps around the outside. That gives me 75 grains of weight up front to start with, which is where front of center (FOC) comes from.
Fletching: four fletch, left helical
I run four fletchings. In my experience, four flies way better than three. I also put a left helical on them, because my arrow naturally turns left when I shoot it.
I want that arrow spinning like a bullet coming downrange. There’s a reason gun barrels are grooved inside: a spinning bullet is more accurate. What I didn’t like about a three-fletch with no helical is that it can knuckleball out of the bow. Some guys shoot it, and there’s nothing wrong with that, but I want my arrow spinning.
Lighted nocks
I run lighted nocks now. Before, I used a wrap so I could see the arrow in flight, but a lighted nock is the best way. It won’t make the arrow fly better, penetrate more, or shoot flatter. What it does is let you see exactly where you hit an animal, and that matters, especially when you’re filming hunts.
The Numbers: Moose Arrow vs. Pronghorn Arrow
Both arrows have the same shaft and the same 75-grain insert. The only difference is the broadhead: 100 grains on one, 125 on the other.
| Pronghorn arrow | Moose arrow | |
|---|---|---|
| Broadhead | 100 grain | 125 grain |
| Weight up front | 175 grains | 200 grains |
| FOC | about 10% | about 13% |
| Total weight | 488 grains | 495 grains |
| Speed | 283.2 fps | 282.7 fps |
| Kinetic energy | about 87 ft-lbs | about 88 ft-lbs |
Nearly identical weight, speed, and energy. The internet would have had them 150 grains apart.
The heavier-front one is my moose arrow. It’s the one I took to Alaska, because I believe the extra front weight gives me a little better penetration. I didn’t get a shot at a bull on that trip, and I wrote about why. But that’s the arrow I’d send at a bull moose, or an elk, or a pronghorn.
Stop Building Arrows for the Species
Here’s my philosophy. Why would I build a 600-grain arrow for moose and a 400-grain arrow for pronghorn? I’m going to build the arrow that performs best: the flattest shot, high speed, good kinetic energy, and the most penetration possible, no matter what animal I’m hunting.
So stop tinkering so much and start practicing, so your arrow goes exactly where you want it to.
Arrow Build FAQ
Do you need a heavier arrow for moose than for pronghorn?
Not in my opinion. My moose arrow weighs 495 grains and my pronghorn arrow 488. I build one arrow that flies flat and gets two holes, and I hunt everything with it.
What is FOC on an arrow?
FOC stands for front of center. It’s how much of the arrow’s weight sits toward the point. More weight up front, from a heavier insert or broadhead, helps penetration. My moose arrow runs about 13% FOC, and my pronghorn arrow about 10%.
How do you calculate arrow kinetic energy?
Multiply arrow weight in grains by speed in feet per second squared, then divide by 450,240. My 495-grain arrow at 282.7 fps comes out to about 88 foot-pounds.
Is four fletch better than three?
In my experience, yes. Four fletchings with a left helical make my arrow spin like a bullet and fly straighter. Plenty of hunters shoot three-fletch and do fine, so test what flies best out of your bow.
Are lighted nocks worth it?
Yes, but not for flight. A lighted nock won’t make your arrow fly better or penetrate more. It lets you see exactly where you hit the animal, which helps you make the right call on the recovery.
Put It to Work
Want to dig deeper into front weight? Read Does FOC (Front Of Center) Even Matter?. If you’re shopping for a bow to go with your arrow, check out the best hunting bows of 2026.
Then go put that arrow on an animal. Our Colorado archery elk hunt in Units 84 and 85, a New Mexico private-land pronghorn hunt with landowner tags, or an archery moose hunt in Alberta are all good places to start. We talk gear on the Hunt Podcast too, or you can talk to one of our consultants about your next bowhunt.
— Kurt